top of page
Search

AI Rage

7 minutes ago
7 min read

I TOLD YOU SO!


There are two words, actually three if you count the so, that can be applied to just about everything in life these days: I told you so.



You name the subject, and there's probably an I told you so attached to it somewhere.


The racing industry? I told you so. The inability of an industry to get out of its own way, recognize an opportunity, and do the right thing even when the right thing is staring it in the face. I told you so.


The internet and social media? I told you so. An enormous waste of human resources, time, energy, and, in some cases, whatever common sense people had left.


And now we arrive at the latest gold rush. Artificial Intelligence.


I told you so.


Apparently, everybody has saddled up, packed their wagons, and headed west in search of AI gold. Much like the original Gold Rush of the 1800s, everybody is convinced there's a fortune waiting in them thar hills. Never mind that most will come back with a little dust in their pockets, a hole in their wallet, and a smaller slice of somebody else's pie.


20 Credits for $299 -- For All Tracks
Buy Now

The rush to AI is not necessarily a rush toward intelligence. In many cases, it's a race to see how little thinking a person can get away with doing.


Just in the last seven days, we've witnessed some pretty remarkable examples of how people are approaching this technology. Human procrastination and laziness have never been more pronounced than they are in this great technological movement to do less.


You have read and heard me going off on Wix.com and Square.com among many that have ruined their platforms with their rush to AI.


And I think handicapping is particularly vulnerable.


We're beginning to lose something that has always been central to handicapping: individuality.


I know handicappers who have turned to AI, and what I'm seeing is a gradual surrender of their own opinions, instincts, interpretations, and processes. Instead of developing an independent opinion, they're running everything through an AI filter and arriving at the same horse everybody else arrives at.


Congratufuckinglations. We've managed to turn one of the most individual pursuits in horse racing into a collective exercise in agreeing with one another.


40 credits get 45 ~ FALL PACKAGE - GOOD ANNYTIME
Buy Now

AI, in its most basic application, is a collection and synthesis of thoughts, ideas, information, and opinions. It can be an extraordinarily useful tool, but let's not confuse information processing with intelligence, or an assembled consensus with independent reasoning.


Here's a simple example.


Let's say ten different people ask AI the same question: Who is the speed of the race at Tin Buck Downs?


AI goes looking for information. It finds what people have already posted, what others have written, and what the prevailing opinion appears to be. It comes back with an answer based on the information available to it.


Now those ten people may very well receive essentially the same answer.


But here's where it gets interesting. Those answers, and the information surrounding them, become part of the larger pool of information that people subsequently reference. Somebody asks another question about who gets the lead, and the machine may draw upon the very same opinions and conclusions that were previously circulated.


We're creating an echo chamber and then congratulating ourselves for having independent thoughts.


Buy 6 mos, gets 7 INCLUDES ALL Winter-Fall EVENTS All-inclusive WiththeWorks
$1,099.00
Buy Now

That's not handicapping. That's outsourcing your opinion.


Handicapping is supposed to involve interpretation. You look at the horse, the race, the pace, the competition, the circumstances, the surface, the trainer, the rider, and a dozen other variables. You form an opinion. You may be right, you may be wrong, and you may get your head handed to you. That's part of the business.


But it's YOUR opinion.


Two competent handicappers can look at the same race, the same past performances, and the same information and come away with completely different conclusions. That's the beauty of the game. That's where the diversity of thought comes from. And that's where opportunities are found.


If everybody is using the same questions, the same filters, and essentially the same information to arrive at the same conclusions, what exactly are we accomplishing?


We're eliminating the very thing that makes handicapping interesting and potentially profitable: independent thought.


And perhaps the bigger issue is that we're losing our common sense along the way.


We no longer seem particularly interested in understanding how something works. We want an answer. We want it immediately. We don't want to do the research, understand the mechanics, challenge the information, or develop our own conclusions. We simply ask a machine to tell us what to think.


There's a considerable difference between using a tool to improve your understanding and using a tool to replace your understanding.


One makes you better. The other makes you dependent.


And this isn't just about horse racing. It's about what happens when we gradually surrender the responsibility of thinking for ourselves. We become comfortable accepting answers without questioning their origin, accuracy, or reasoning. We begin to believe that because something is delivered in a polished paragraph, it must be intelligent.


It isn't necessarily so.


Buy 100 credits get 125 for All Seasons WiththeWorks
$999.00
Buy Now

Just for fun, I'm going to ask AI a very generic question:

What is the primary handicapping tool in horse racing?


I have a pretty good idea what the answer will look like. And I'm curious whether it will explain the reasoning behind its answer or simply regurgitate the prevailing consensus found across the internet.


so, I asked the question to AI - What is the primary tools for handicapping....


Well, here you have it. We asked AI what the primary tool for handicapping Thoroughbred horse racing was, and it came back with the Past Performances.


Buy Yearly All Inclusive Get 14 months - All Tracks- - INCL. BC AND TOP TRACKS
$1,999.00
Buy Now

Speed figures, pace figures, class, competition, running styles, distance, surface, recent form, trainer statistics, jockey statistics, and workouts.


Wow!


the only thing missing was exclaiming that all the winners are right there in the Past Performances. No shit AI Sherlock!


I believe I read that in a handicapping book about 40 years ago. In fact, I believe some of us were doing it before the fuckinginternet, before social media, before somebody decided everything needed an algorithm, and certainly before AI became the latest gold mine of regurtitation of past ideas. There is literally nothing new, nothing substantial within its response. You got dust.


So we have this great technological revolution, everybody is rushing to the hills looking for answers, and the machine comes back with what handicappers have known for generations.


Buy 85 Credits get 95 for WithTheWorks -Good anytime - Any Track
$799.00
Buy Now

That's not a knock on the information. It's a reminder that information and intelligence aren't necessarily the same thing.


The real question was never what information goes into handicapping. The question is what you do with it, how you interpret it, what you recognize that somebody else doesn't, and whether you have the conviction to make your own decision.


AI can tell you what's in the book. It can't automatically give you the experience of having spent 40 years reading it.


Welcome to the Gold Rush. Apparently, we've rediscovered the Past Performances.


Because there's another little problem here. If you ask the same question repeatedly, you're likely to get variations of the same collective answer. That doesn't mean you've learned anything new. It means you've found another way to confirm what was already out there.

I'm not suggesting AI has no place in our lives, well maybe I am. There are legitimate applications, and there are ways to use technology to save time, organize information, identify patterns, and make better-informed decisions.


But there's a difference between having a tool in your toolbox and allowing the toolbox to do the work while you stand there holding the hammer.


At some point, we have to ask ourselves whether we're becoming more intelligent or simply becoming more efficient at avoiding the work required to think. I think the latter is more likely.


In handicapping, I would suggest that the person who can still look at a race, develop an original opinion, recognize something others have missed, and have the conviction to stand behind that opinion has a considerable advantage.


You cannot manufacture that individuality by asking a computer to give you somebody else's collective wisdom.


So, by all means, saddle up and head for those AI gold fields. Just remember that when everybody comes back with the same gold nugget, there's probably not much gold left in the mine.


So the next time you hear some fella bragging about how he got the 6/5 favorite through AI, understand something: there's probably a reason that horse was 6/5. Everybody else got the same horse!


Congratufuckinglations. You just used the latest technological breakthrough to identify the horse the entire betting public already identified.


AI is the biggest load of bullshit I've seen this side of a B-plus workout being marketed to the unsuspecting masses as some kind of inside information.


And that's the part that bothers me most. People are being sold the idea that they're getting an informational advantage when, in many cases, they're simply getting a repackaged version of popular opinion. Worse, people are already manipulating the information environment by flooding the internet with opinions, narratives, and conclusions designed to attract attention. Those opinions become part of the information pool that AI systems may draw upon.


Think about that for a minute.


You can influence what gets repeated, what gets noticed, and ultimately what gets presented as the prevailing answer. And the unsuspecting user believes he's receiving independent intelligence.


No, you're receiving a consensus with a fresh coat of paint.


  • THERE IS NO LOGIC!

  • THERE IS NO DEDUCTIVE REASONING!

  • THERE IS NO DECISION MAKING!


  • BUT THERE IS A TON OF REGURGITATION!


Meanwhile, the individual handicapper, the person who studies the horse, questions the figures, challenges the conventional wisdom, and comes to his own conclusions, is in danger of becoming an endangered species.


You wanted an edge and wound up standing in the same line as everybody else.


You wanted inside information and got the public's opinion.


You wanted to think outside the box and let somebody else build the box for you.


Congrats! You just got herded, you are a sheep



And when the dust settles, the computer won't be cashing your tickets.


I told you so.

 
 
bottom of page